A well-known “unbody” homicide expert, Ted DiBiaselisting two possible areas where the murderer might have disposed of Nancy Guthrie’s Body. Nancy is missing More than three weeks. Her body has not been found, although many experts believe she may have died.
“Even considering the suspicious circumstances of this case… the most common disposal area for ‘bodyless’ murders is in the water. The second is what I would call, kind of buried in the woods or left in the woods,” DiBiase told Brian Entin, NewsNationclarifying that he was referring to outdoor activities in general.
Learn more | What is unusual about Nancy Guthrie’s disappearance? Explain how this case differs from other missing persons cases
Why search efforts matter
DiBiase also stressed the importance of conducting searches.
“To me, there are two reasons why not doing a search would be problematic,” DiBiase said. “One, because you ignored the opportunity to find the body, which is crucial. But two, when you go to trial, you want to be able to say to the jury, this is all the searches we did, we established that she couldn’t have walked away on her own, she couldn’t have escaped, she couldn’t have killed herself. Any of those things.” Because you don’t know unless you do a very thorough search and you’re able to say to the jury, ‘We can rule out other possibilities for what happened, and all that’s left is that this person was present the night she disappeared, when she seemed to be missing, and that’s the only logical thing to do. ‘”
Learn more | Nancy Guthrie Update: Ex-FBI Agent Shares 4 Chilling Theories During Search, ‘Death at the Hands of Porch Guy…’
Investigators have not publicly disclosed plans for further large-scale searches. However, DiBiase believes continued efforts could help find answers and future prosecutions.



